Wednesday, 2 July 2008

MA Final Year.

I can't begin to describe how difficult I've found this year. As of the 17th of May, I have been more-or-less finished, with only my dissertation still to write. That is due in the first week of September, and I have one of five chapters already written. I'm gradually working my way through it, and have a good chunk of my research done, even if it's not written. I'm in a good position.

But I've struggled to get here. In my first year, I had two modules. These were CRMR (Classical Research Methods and Resources) and Akkadian. I found Akkadian difficult, although CRMR was innocuous enough. The grammar gave me no trouble, although I did find remembering the vocabulary harder than I have for any other language. That's because it was so different. At the end of the day, all languages have the same kind of grammar rules; even if the patterns are different, they are the same kind of patterns. This is true of Akkadian and French, Latin and ancient Greek. The words, though... the words themselves were very different. Even when transliterated and then normalised out of cuneiform, they looked different. My favourite Akkadian word, kalbatum, looks normal enough when it's normalised like this. Before this stage, when just transliterated from cuneiform to latin letters, it looks like this: ka-al-ba-tum. For anyone that speaks an ancient language, that's just weird. It's hard to explain.

Anyway, the point is that last year was hard. Nevertheless I got through it and did well. This year has been harder. This year I've had only two modules again, but both have been really heavy on the work side. One of them ridiculously so. I've had "Religious Life in the Roman Near East" with Ted Kaizer and "Greek Sacred Regulations" with Andrej PetroviƧ. The latter has been fun, and while there has been iffy moments that have involved presentations and plenty of difficult prep work, I've enjoyed every single seminar. The former was hard. I didn't like it. I didn't like the subject matter, despite being a Near East student previously, with my study of Akkadian. I think, although it did pique my interest at times, I disliked it so much because of the sheer amount of work Ted set us.

Durham University assesses its students in two ways. The first is with a piece of Formative work, submitted early in the year. After this, there is a piece of Summative work. The Formative assessment is a minor submission, worth a low percentage of the overall grade. Basically, it is an opportunity for a lecturer to be sure that you are working well and identify areas that you need help.

The average module is as I've described it above. One Formative, one Summative. This is how Greek Sacred Regulations worked. Our Formative was a presentation to be given before an audience. We had to read and analyse an article, and present this analysis. It was a piece of piss, audience aside. Our Summative was a 5,000 word essay on a subject of our choice. In Religious Life, however, Ted set us a lot of work. On top of 10+ articles and 4 or 5 books to read in every three week period, we had an essay to write. A 2,000 word essay should not have been too challenging, but my god, they were. He set the questions, and he certainly didn't do us any favours. They were hard. It was difficult to get the 2,000 words. It was difficult to argue the points. I never scored higher than a 2.2 on any of these essays. Four Formative essays; three more than the standard. On top of this, for our final seminar, he set a presentation, to be given in the class. This was harder than the essay. To talk for twelve minutes is to say more than 2,000 words. Add in the pressure having to present your finding to your peers rather than merely write them out and hand them to a lecturer where your marks can be kept private, and it's difficult.

I hated that class.

I got my results today, and is it any surprise that I didn't do too well in it?

From: HAUBOLD J.
Sent: 02 July 2008 14:38
To: POLLOCK J.L.
Subject: MA Results

Dear Julie,

I have just spoken to Graduate School about your MA results. They will not send out individual marks, but they have now given us the go-ahead to pass them on to you. So, here goes:

Religious Life 60
Greek Sacred Regulations 63

I would like to see all MA students this coming Thursday (4th July) between 10am and 12noon, to discuss their marks and prepare for their work over summer. Please do drop by on Thursday morning, whenever is most convenient for you.

Best wishes,

Johannes

I am surprised and disappointed by my mark in Sacred Regulations. I thought I did well in that essay. In fact, I thought I did well in my Religious Life Summative, but Ted had been telling me all year that my essays simply weren't good enough, and although I tried a drastically different technique for my final essay, I didn't really expect him to mark it high. I'm not blaming him; clearly it's my technique that isn't good enough, but I could have done with being helped when I asked for it. Sacred Regulations, though... *le sigh*

Oh well.

I would just like to add this, for your amusement and my frustration.

Dear July,

Apologies for the mistake in my email: the meeting for all MA students is tomorrow, 3rd July. Please let me know if you cannot make the meeting, so that we can arrange an alternative time.

Best wishes,

Johannes


Dear Johannes,

Tomorrow is not a problem, although I am glad I re-checked my email this evening or I would not have checked tomorrow in enough time to make it. I shall try to aim for eleven o'clock.

See you in the morning!

Julie (Not July! ;) )

Grr.

2 comments:

MsTypo said...

At least you'll have this chance to sit down with them and see what they did or didn't like before you get too far into your dissertation. I know how hard you've worked on these two classes this year - be proud of your work. You've said in the past that Johna and Thed are tough/mean graders. You're dead brilliant and you know it. In the end grades don't matter - only that lovely piece of paper that says that yo're a master. (Ohh baby!)

And if all else fails i'll go and beat them up!! It'll give me an excuse to visit you and work out some of rage issues. *grin*

Can i start calling you July now?! :D :D Can i call you Master July?! *rowl*

Aurenna said...

No you may not!!!!